Was VAR the Real Champion of AFCON 2025? Inside the Controversy

AFCON 2025 will be remembered for more than the trophies. For many, the tournament’s story was decided not on the pitch, but in the VAR room.

Across multiple matches, pivotal decisions shaped outcomes, fueled debates, and left players, coaches, and fans questioning the fairness of African football’s flagship event. From penalty calls in the dying minutes to disallowed goals in knockout rounds, VAR’s intervention was as decisive as any striker’s finish.

The Key Controversies

1. Last-Minute Penalty Decisions

In the semi-finals, a penalty awarded in the 94th minute sparked uproar. Fans claimed the decision was inconsistent with earlier calls; analysts pointed to a rigid VAR protocol. Senegal advanced, but the match left lingering questions about fairness versus regulation.

2. Disallowed Goals

Several goals were overturned after VAR review, often with minimal explanation to players or the public. The discontent highlighted a broader issue: transparency and communication remain weak in African football officiating.

3. Referees Under Pressure

AFCON 2025 exposed referees to unprecedented scrutiny. Data from CAF shows that over 40% of VAR interventions led to social media backlash, and nearly 25% were questioned by pundits as inconsistent. Officials now face not only the game but public perception and political pressure.

Who Really Benefits?

While fans and players complained, the real beneficiaries of VAR were more subtle:

• CAF strengthened centralized control over officiating and match review.
• Sponsors and broadcasters enjoyed high drama and global attention.
• Foreign scouts watched how players reacted under pressure, making talent decisions in real time.

As one referee insider noted:

“VAR isn’t just technology; it’s power. And power often decides who wins before the final whistle.”

The Hidden Costs

VAR controversies come at a price:

• Fan trust — repeated disputed calls risk alienating supporters.
• Player morale — careers and reputations can hinge on split-second decisions.
• National federation credibility — when decisions appear inconsistent, leadership is questioned.

Looking Forward: Lessons for AFCON 2027

If AFCON 2025 taught us anything, it is that VAR is here to stay — but African football must integrate it responsibly. Transparency, accountability, and clear communication are essential.

Teams and federations that plan for VAR, understand its protocols, and train players to adapt will have a competitive advantage. The lesson is clear: the next AFCON may not be won on skill alone, but on who navigates controversy best.

Florsport International

We document African football so the world can never rewrite it.